Like vs. Become a fan

Posted by Aditya in Social media marketing,The social web on April 23, 2010

Anandan Pillai, a PhD student at MDI, Gurgaon and a Summer Research Fellow at Superchooha writes on his blog about the new introduction of ‘Like’ buttons by Facebook. leaving behind the ‘Become a fan’ tag.

And he talks about it from a perspective that most of us didn’t see – from a brand’s point of view. And he makes some solid arguments to prove his proposals right.

However, what surprised me was the context of argument, almost everyone argued from the perspective of individual users (read “customers” if you are marketer). Now, this took me aback!!!

I feel, when someone says “I like this”, it doesn’t make bring a kick in me, because I feel ya you might me 1 of other billion odd people who might be liking this. On the contrary, when you say me “I am a fan of Facebook”, this ushers the adrenaline in me and makes my stupid brain think, why the hell this person is fan of some strange animal called “facebook”, what’s so special about it?, and this curiosity leads to search for information about “facebook” (which means receiving new unique visitors), getting acclimatized with it (increasing chances of conversion), and maybe becoming a fan of it too (yeahh that’s my target at the end of the day). Does it sound good (if not great)???? Hit me back if any marketer disagrees to it.

I personally think it was a good move for businesses everywhere, maybe not from a marketing point of view because Facebook definitely wants to expand the radius of its social graph, unless it suffers the fate of Friendster and MySpace. To do that, Facebook needs to become the ubiquitous social identity. The de facto. The omnipresent. Now to do that Facebook needs to enter websites and every online operations. And by killing the more passionate word called ‘fan’ Facebook enters a more neutral ground of ‘liking’ which everyone can live with. And doesn’t mind indulging in.

I can just be interested in something and I can like it. Thus putting it into my social stream and exposing the ‘liked’ content to my friends thus making it go viral. More likes >> More content into social streams >> More hits back to website >> Facebook = happy and Content owner = Happy!

And I have seen this again and again. Brand managers get so fascinated by the phrase ‘My brand has x000 fans on Facebook’ that they start forgetting the real value of the word ‘fan’ .. A fan is a wildly passionate evangelist of your brand who loves it. Revels in it. And tells others proudly about his fandom.

How many fans of a page are actually at that stage? Doesn’t it conclude that most of them just liked your brand anyways and were NOT fans.

Related posts:

  1. 4 Easy Ways to Engage your Facebook Fans
  2. Is like better than love?

Tags: , ,

  • Well, having worked with a digital agency, I'm not too convinced about social media. Especially, the way it is handled. I like the case-study, cause it threw a lot on light on how social media could actually translate into greater ROI. Also, social media can be leveraged for social causes, but it seldom is used.
    The edition I was referring to was March 2010. If you visit a site called gigapedia (dot) com, you may be able to download it.
  • great! would do that :)
    you should have a look at our other resources for understanding our approach to SM.

    we understand the 'not too convinced about social media' part ..
    its not being handled properly because its still being looked at from a digital (read impressions and clicks) point of view. and ROI is still measures in CTRs

    ROI should be measured from dollars to dollars! :)
    We would be updating with some of our case studies soon
  • You guys should read a case study on social marketing in the HBR on some coffee shop in the US. The research was in-depth, with a focus on walk-ins.
  • thanks! could you share the issue number for HBR ... :)
    how did it relate to this topic?
blog comments powered by Disqus

say a quick hello

  1. *
  2. *
  3. *
  4. *
 

cforms contact form by delicious:days

subscribe

Get updates in your inbox:

 Subscribe in a reader

Life @ Superchooha


recent